Thread:HowlingWolf83/@comment-26268675-20190323080044/@comment-37498053-20190327093731

You did it really quickly, nice job my friend.

Well, first of all i want say isn't in disapproval way or destructive critic, is just a personal feeling related with my experience in the first try to understand how was sort the page, so please read this from the humly like it was wrote.

ANALYTIC

Ok, my first impression was.... why is so long the page? So i went to understand why. In that precise moment i had noticed that the tables seems a single huge block, have specific titles for every section of course, but is difficult for the view detect them at naked eye.

After multiple times scrolling the page to up and down i was be able to understand the logic behind the sort. It's separated folowing this priority, "Ki, Atk and Def", and starting from this point separated on diferent blocks.


 * All Types Supports Ki + Stat Boost
 * Super/Extreme Types Supports Ki and Stat Boost
 * Category Supports Ki and Stat Boost
 * Triple Types Supports Ki + Stat Boost
 * Duo Types Supports Ki + Stat Boost

Breaking down it like this, looks really good and seems easy and intuitive find whatever you want, but actually is far away.

This system not allow join characters in the same row and almost every row have a single character inside, so the page is extremely long (i know that a lot characters have a specific condition). Also there are character with similar boost arround of whole page and it gives a messy feel.

Well, until here the analytic. Of course your sorting have a lot logic and i'm not saying that it's bad, but thinking on the common user, who will not go to break down the sort i think it's a bit difficult to understand.

Ok, i have not a magic rod to do the perfect page but a critic isn't a constructive critic if not offer any alternative, so i will try to explain how i see it and what things i would change (and how) to do a most confortable experience.

PROPOSAL

Well, the first thing i would change is the priority, i know that it was not your intention, but indirectly you're assuming that KI is most important than ATK and DEF, and the ATK y most important than DEF, when actually the most important is what the user need in each moment.

My proposal is sort them together starting by stats, so the characters which have most boost are at top. For example a character with +2 +0% +40% would be above of +3 +30% +30% (even being more useful the second, but seems better to find), and when the stats are the same keep in mind the KI. So character with +3 +20% +20% would be above of +2 +20%+20%

About the blocks that you're using i think that "All Types Supports Ki + Stat Boost" and "Super/Extreme Types Supports Ki and Stat Boost" can be joined, since is already specified in the table to what types/class/categories provides the boost. And the same for "Triple Types Supports Ki + Stat Boost" and "Duo Types Supports Ki + Stat Boost".

And now i arrived to the most difficult part, sorting the caracters which have a condition. From the first time that i saw the condition column i hate it with all my forces, it provides a lot headaches and gives a dirty feel at moment to specify the condition, specially when is a long text. So i propose delete it completely and use other method, here my proposal.

Or maybe other alternative (i thouhgt on this making the previously xD)

Ok, until here my try to make The Bible part 2, i know that's a long text to read but i'm really interested on make a really good page because time ago that i had it in my list of things to do.

Pretty possible there a lot things that i had not in count in my proposal and by any reason it would not a good idea, so go ahead, is better be critic and have a consolidated idea before start to work instead have to change it later ;)